false
OasisLMS
en,es
Login
Catalog
Who Decides? What 1,452 Blinded Fundraising Decisi ...
Slides
Slides
Back to course
Pdf Summary
The presentation argues that the key question for AI in fundraising is not simply whether to use it, but who should make and own decisions.<br /><br />A blind benchmark asked 363 experienced fundraising and nonprofit professionals to compare practitioner and AI recommendations across 16 realistic scenarios, producing 1,452 judgments. Overall, participants slightly favored practitioners (51.4%) over AI (48.6%), a difference that was not statistically reliable. Instead, preferences depended on the workflow. Practitioners were favored when decisions required interpreting donor intent, managing relationships, or assigning ownership—for example, clarifying an ambiguous restricted gift. AI was favored for some structured, operational tasks, such as trip planning, stewardship scheduling, and preparing preliminary prospect profiles.<br /><br />Preference did not determine authority. Only 1.7% of judgments supported AI acting without individual review; 77.5% called for human approval, human-led action, or no AI involvement. Respondents prioritized visible controls: approval workflows, the ability to edit or override, and access to sources or evidence. The study is an industry benchmark, not peer-reviewed research, and uses a convenience sample and hypothetical scenarios.<br /><br />The presentation recommends assigning authority by workflow: AI can inform, draft, recommend, or execute bounded and reversible actions, while sensitive or ambiguous situations should stop and escalate to a person. Institutions should inventory AI uses, run limited pilots with safeguards and stop conditions, and review whether to expand, revise, pause, or retire each use.<br /><br />Purdue for Life Foundation describes its AI program as a way to save staff time, improve access to information, and support better preparation and decisions—while strengthening human connection. Its principles emphasize value, data security, human judgment, and alignment with existing platforms. People remain accountable, and AI adoption is intended to be practical, iterative, and guided by staff input.
Keywords
AI fundraising
human judgment
decision authority
donor intent
nonprofit benchmarking
approval workflows
stewardship scheduling
restricted gifts
human-AI collaboration
data security
×
Please select your language
1
English